Monday, 11 February 2013

Elements of game design, part six: visual composition

Composition is something I have never really understood, I get that having a certain layout or focus in a photograph of piece of art is important and can effect how appealing the piece is overall. But I don't understand how or why that works, or what the actual method is. I've heard of the rule of thirds and the golden ratio but have never looked into it and tried to properly understand what they mean. I don't understand composition fully, so I don't use it in my work to full effect and this probably has a negative effect on my work. I haven't really looked into composition before but if it helps my work then now is probably a good time to start. Here is what I learnt:

Composition is like an art form in itself. The idea of composition comes from way back in the Renaissance, with the guidelines used to create photographs today established centuries before the first camera was even invented. So the idea of composition and what makes an appealing image isn't new.


Rule of thirds photography


Composition is basically the balance of everything in a photograph or piece of artwork. As humans we like symmetry and look for patterns or appealing layouts which make us like something.
The rule of thirds and the golden mean are two of the most well known methods of setting up composition in a piece. Both methods provide a means to capture the background in the photo as well a creating a compelling piece that guides the eye of the viewer.


With the rule of thirds you divide the frame into three parts, then place the main parts of the image on the green dots.
 

The golden mean works in the same way, you draw a line from corner to corner of the frame. Then draw a line from the opposite corners to the line. The subjects of the image should lie at the intersection of these two lines. This technique was developed in ancient Greece and has become less well known over time.







These rules are the basic building blocks of composition. The aim is to create a visually compelling  image that captures the attention of the viewer. The rule of thirds and the golden mean aim to create a composition that leads the eye of the viewer around and tells a story behind the photograph.

Golden Mean photography


These are the main rules of using composition, but there are other elements that will enhance a piece of work if used correctly. These include;

Finding a Clear Centre of Interest

Find something that captures your eye and interest. Try to avoid distracting objects or shadows.

Fill the Frame  Get the subject into the frame so there is no doubt what the photo is all about.

Present a Clear Message Try to avoid anything that would distracts from the main subject.
Compose Boldly Look for repetition or patterns, diagonals, contrasting colours and shapes. They all help to make an interesting image.
Create Depth Put objects in front and behind your subject but a little out of focus. This isolates the subject and helps bring focus to it.
Light and Dark Use light and dark carefully, light tones advance while dark tones retreat. Most people look at the lighter portions of an image first.

Shapes
Framing with shapes
Vertical and horizontal are bad, diagonal is good. Psychologists say that instincts honed back our caveman days are responsible for that. Diagonal images are visually more interesting that vertical and horizontal.

Framing
This is the use of elements in the foreground to frame the object in focus.

Lines Vertical lines emphasise power, strength, and height.
Horizontal lines express stability and width.
Diagonal lines express dynamic energy.
Curving lines express sensuality.




I found this website very useful in learning about composition - http://photoinf.com/

Bits of 3D

Trash
The first 3D work I have done in months, I wasn't looking forward to it at all. I was worried I had completely forgot how to use the program and was going to have to learn it all over again. Trash is also pretty dull. I managed to get into modelling pretty quickly, but it wasn't that difficult modelling rubbish to be honest.


I used the project to try get my own style into my work. I focused more on the textures and putting my art style into it, rather than the modelling and textures on the rubbish.



I enjoyed the project more because I could put my graffiti into it, which i digipainted just for this project. I think this affected my mark though, I got good marks for my textures but my modelling and other textures suffered because I spent too much time on my own bits. In future I will need to find a better balance.


Building
I didn't enjoy this project. I had several ideas to begin with but thought referencing was going to be a big problem. I decided to do a building that I thought was interesting and cool, the ghost busters building in New York. I was able to use street view and reference from stills of the films to get the general idea of the building and how it looks but it still wasn't easy to make it. We don't have any buildings in the UK that really look like New York fire houses.



I found modelling difficult, the building is actually quite plain with not much detail. With a large tri budget I found it hard to find the places to put the detail into. This meant I had some very dense areas of tris and others with very little.

I found the textures quite difficult to get right aswell, I had to use bits of other references images that I have gathered over the past year to help make the texture sheets.



I think my building is a good representation of the Ghost Busters building and several people managed to recognise it, which is good. I tried to stick to the reference I had, but this made it look quite empty and plain especially compared to the other buildings. I'm not sure how well it fits with the other buildings, I could of picked a better building to do, but I like the Ghost Busters.
So oh well.


So year 2 huh


Its February, a few months into the 2nd year of the course and I have managed to get no blogs done. Awesome. I now have to cram them in like crazy so I don't get a massive FAIL stamped on my face, and I hate writing. I didn't post any blogs but I apparently drafted a few which might help speed things up abit.

This is the blog I drafted ages ago about coming back to uni and starting the second year, in September. I'm glad it doesn't say much about 'keeping up with blogs and meeting all deadlines' because in hindsight I would of looked like a knob to post that now.


Well the summer break is over and now it's back to work. Summer went faster then I would of liked and I got nothing done that I wanted to. I took a few weeks to myself at the start to relax and destress, but once I had done that I was then busy sorting out getting married and all that comes with it. By the time it was over and all our friends and family had gone it was August and just before our last friend left I broke my right thumb. Breaking my thumb was a massive waste of time for me I, I had a huge cast that prevented me doing everything that involves your hands. I lost 8 weeks of time when I was about to start doing some of the things I had wanted to do over the summer, by the time I got my cast off there was just over 2 weeks left before going back. I managed to do a fair bit of drawing in that time, doing timed drawings and doing as much as I could to get the movement back in my thumb.

It was like this, seriously...for a thumb.

Theres some things I really wanted to learn over summer that I haven't had chance to, like Zbrush mainly. I have wanted to practise and get to grips with that program for a while now but have struggled to find the time to get it in, and I haven't looked at it at all over the summer. I'm hoping that I'll have chance to do something with Zbrush in year 2 and it might help my 3D work get better.
I also wanted to practise digi-painting more over summer but my cast has stopped me being able to do that. I'm not a big fan of digital drawing/painting I prefer traditional methods much more, but I'm still planning of putting some time into improving at digi work.


So now that the 2nd year is here what do I want from this year, I still don't really know. I'm just gonna have to go with it, until I get to the point where I know what I'm doing or want to do. While all the normal uni work is going on I am making time to do the kinda things I want to do, like life drawing and anatomy and then I'm gonna go from there. When I feel I know the human body enough I can move onto the next thing and build from it.
Its all about building things up.

I'm kind of hoping I have more time in the second year to practise the things I want to and work in the ways/styles that I like most. I'd like to have more freedom to work on ideas that I have and do them in a style that means more to me.

Its very late, but that was my blog for the start of year 2.










Sunday, 15 April 2012

Task 11: Elements of game design, part four: environment

The environment is just as important as the characters within a game, without it we'd have nothing to do, no where to go or explore and there wouldn't be a game. When an environment is done well it is often overlooked, given the amount of time and effort that is put into it it is unfortunate, but it does mean the environment has been done well.
An interesting looking environment


While playing a game players don't often stop to admire or study parts of the environment unless something has stood out to them, this means it has either been so beautifully it is attention grabbing, or, more likely, it has been poorly and detracts from the believability of the game. In general if the environment is believable it won't stand out and will go undetected, comfortably making the world believable and interesting.

The environment is therefore key to if we really believe the games world or if it stands out to us as wrong. Games have in the past gone both ways on the scale. An example of good environment design is the Bioshock series. The  first game is based in the underwater city of Rapture set in the 1960s, the city is left in disarray following a social collapse and a war taking place. You enter the environment through a dramatic decent to the city via a bathysphere. When you get to Rapture the environment is instantly eye catching and stunning. The environment designers on the game did an amazing job of bringing in elements and styles of the 1960s into futuristic ideas and setting. You believe the environment is possible for the time and everything found within is also believable and in keeping.

Rapture's setting


The feel of Bioshock is fantastic with the environment and characters really lending to the games enjoyability, there is nothing within Bioshock that stands out as wrong or out of place. Every aspect of the game has been developed and planned to lend itself to Bioshock's story and the events that have taken place. We never get to actually see what happened to Rapture before we got there so the story is told and understood through what we see in the environment, and it works!

A scene inside Bioshock, easily readable.


A game that's environment didn't work so well was Stalker. Despite knowing what happened in the game and why the environment had gotten to its current state it just wasn't as believable or enjoyable. The game often felt too large and empty given the way it is played and was later modded to improve that. I found the characters and environment dull, atmospheric and uninteresting. I found myself having to apply alot of user made mods to the game in order to make it playable, which shouldn't be necessary.

Stalker looking abit bland and boring.



From what I have read and experienced some general guidelines for environment design would be;
  1. the environment should guide the player, creating meaningful play
  2. the environment should communicate the purpose of an area
  3. the environment should  set a believable scene
  4. the environment should tell the story of the game so the player can understand and assume what has happened without needing to be shown or told
  5. the environment needs to be interesting and believable and hint to a larger world outside of what the player sees
  6. the environment should be immerse and avoid things that would disconnect the player from the game

 

Task 10: Elements of game design, part three: character

Character design isn't something I really think about, this is mainly because the games I tend to play don't rely on good character design to be fun.These are games such as real time strategies and action adventure games. I think the game type I play most however is the first person shooter genre.

While characters are an important part of games they are often over looked in the genres I play, especially first person shooters, meaning there aren't very many characters that have stood out to me as memorable over recent years.

I can't see me.
 I think this is mainly due to the fact that you never see the character you play in first person shooters, they don't often talk or interact with the environment so they don't need to be designed or interesting. They are just a shell for the player and we're what gives them character. First person shooter games are often based around 'running and gunning' gameplay which doesn't give much chance or need for interaction with the environment so we never get to see how or feel how our character is relating or fitting into the world. I often find other characters within first person shooters to be some what dull and uninteresting if not unbelievable, they don't normally have a real sense of depth, this may be due to the fact you don't tend to spend any real length of time around other characters during gameplay and they aren't really necessary within the game.

Despite the fact first person shooters tend not to have awesome character design, I still find them enjoyable and fun to play, because the characters don't really make or break the game and you never need a real sense of attachment to any of them in order to enjoy the game.

Other game genres however, such as role playing games, need to have more believable characters that have good design because the way they look, act and interact with us makes more of a difference. Within these games the character we play also has much more design gone into them as the way we connect to them becomes an important part of how much we enjoy the game. Games that are played within the 3rd person perspective also tend to have alot more effort put into the way our characters look, feel and move as we can see every move they make and if it doesn't look realistic we wont believe it and ultimately dislike it.

Cloud


Character design then is an important part of making a game believable and fun. The challenge is to make characters that are realistic and believable within their given environment and setting of the game. Character design relates to everything about a character, their history, accent, movement, facial expressions and the way they dress. Everything must work together believably in order for the character to make sense and fit within the world so that they don't stand out as wrong.

While some games require characters to be deeply developed to fit, others work well due to strong art design. One of my favourite game characters of all time is 'War' from the game 'Darksiders'. This isn't because his character has a deep back history, emotional connection or sense of humour, its because he looks bad ass.

He looks awesome!


I'm instantly drawn to the Darksiders game and the characters within it because the artistic style of the game is awesome. The way the world and characters are designed isn't realistic but it is all believable in relation to each other which creates a fun game experience. The Darksider's style makes everything within the game bulky, bold and huge, if they had stuck a weedy main character into it like Link, the game would be rubbish. It works because no matter how big the world is or how nasty and huge the enemies are, War looks and feels like he can take it all on, despite being smaller, and that's down to his design. War isn't very deeply designed and he doesn't have a real emotional background but that is also part of his design, we don't really relate to him as a character but he is believable within the Darksiders world and that's why he works.

And he fits!


I think an important part of character design is relating them to the genre and world they are from. There is no point in creating an emotionally deep soldier for an FPS unless it is the point of the game because it would be unnecessary, overlooked and it just wouldn't fit. But it would be equally as bad to find a poorly designed shell of a character in an RPG that we just cant connect to. Characters are an important part of games that help to fill the world within a game and make it believable, but how they are designed needs to work with the game itself. 

Monday, 19 March 2012

Self Portrait

When I did my self portraits I decided to do them in the style I always used to draw in and one that I find more comfortable doing.
I've always found comic book styles interesting and inspiring and I've practised drawing in them more than any others. When I was growing up I would always copy images that I liked from comic books so its a style I'm used to and enjoy doing. Before coming on this course being a comic book artist has always been something I think I would of really enjoyed doing.


Portrait practise.


Since coming on the course I've pushed myself to draw more realistically and from life instead of photographs as much as possible. It has been quite difficult for me at times and when I get most stressed out at drawing I tend to revert to my comic book style.

I feel much more confident in my ability to draw in a come book style rather than a realistic one which impacts the strength of my drawings.
(left) comic book style, (right) drawn from life
For my final piece I wanted to draw from life properly using a mirror, rather than a photograph, I think this gets me to concentrate more on what I'm doing and produce a better image. I took me around 8-9 hours to do and I'm pleased with the outcome. I made the decision to use my comic book style to draw the image rather than trying to do a more realistic one. I think the style works well, with solid pencil markings and my confidence in using the style shows.

Self portrait final

Saturday, 11 February 2012

Elements of game design, part two: art direction for games

When I think of 'art director' I think of someone who does just that, they direct the way something looks, flows and feels artistically, whether it be a video game or a film. During our last critical studies group we watched some of the development interviews from Black Hawk down and I found them really interesting. I have always really liked Ridley Scott's work and the films he works on but haven't always understood exactly why I enjoy them so much. Learning more about him through interviews with people hes worked with was eye opening. I think an important part about being an art director is having strong roots in art yourself and being able to visualise and then communicate this well and I think this is something Ridley Scott can do.
Due to his artistic background he has a fantastic understanding of light and how to use it in his films to give the most effect and feeling. People find him much better to work with because he can communicate his creative vision through drawings, something other art directors might not be able to do.


Ridley Scott

I know there is more to being an art director than I realised, so I looked for what exactly you need to do to be one in the games industry today. This is a job listing at one of EA's studios -

EA LOGO

Art Director - Gothenburg
The Art Director is responsible for the visual style and quality of all assets created by the team. This includes in-game and front-end menu assets, web sites and branding.
Responsible for the initial high concepts behind visual style, the Art Director communicates their vision by creating key drawings, concept images, mood boards, colour swatches, documentation and example assets.
The Art Director works with the project’s Senior Producer to ensure the art direction fits with the overall project goals and they also work closely with the team’s game and web artists to realise this vision.
Given this is a small, nimble team with a start up mentality, the Art Director needs to be ready to get their hands dirty by also contributing to the production of game, menu and web assets.
You will also be actively involved in hiring new art staff into the team, as well as liaising with contractors and outsourcing groups.

You have a deep understanding of several 2D and 3D software packages. An advanced understanding of motion principles and/or training in areas such as classical animation. During your 3+ years of professional experience you have been responsible for leading and inspiring art production teams. To join our team, you must demonstrate solid communication and problem solving abilities. You must be strategic, as well as have an eye for detail and commitment to deadlines, delivering high quality art on time and on budget.

Experience and Qualifications
• Prior games industry experience or film/television production, or on line experience are each a major plus
• Prior experience as Art Director or Lead artist is preferable
• Solid understanding of art and development practises
• Broad interest in aspects of visual art outside of video and computer games

Demo reel requirements
• Conceptual communication
• Composition
• Colour
• Light
• Motion
• Front End and Typography
• Presentation skills
• Craftsmanship
• Breadth of creative styles.

Jonathan Jacques-BelletĂȘte,
Art Director for Deus Ex: Human Revolution
Wow. Although its great to set your sights high, being an art director seems beyond me right now. I might well get there at some point but given what they have to do I'm not sure I'd ever want to! The art director is responsible for the visual style and quality of all assets created by the team, this includes in-game and front-end menu assets, web sites and branding. That seems like alot of responsibility and not something I'm sure I'd ever want to take on. The art director is tasked with visualising and communicating an idea and then bringing together everything that is produced to unify the vision. The art director is in charge of the overall visual appearance and how it communicates visually, stimulates moods, contrasts features, and psychologically appeals to a target audience. In smaller development groups the art director is also tasked with producing artwork or 3D assets along with everything else so they need to have a good working understanding of both 3D and 2D. Art directors, in short then, are very talented people! They require a huge amount of vision and knowledge and the ability to lead and inspire other people, with years of experience in the industry.



An interview with the art director behind Deus Ex: Human Revolution!
http://playstationlifestyle.net/2011/08/18/psls-presents-jonathan-jacques-belletete-art-director-for-deus-ex-human-revolution/